What I’m Cooking: Meringue Dream Cake

I love to cook. If you know me at all, you definitely know this about me. What you may not know about me is that I have a very large collection of cookbooks (I dream about the day I will have somewhere to store them all in the same place). And you may also not know that I have a mildly out of control obsession with Pinterest. Put all of that together, and I constantly have a unbelievably long list of recipes I want to cook. I like to come up with my own version of classic recipes, like pumpkin pie or boeuf bourguignon, but I also really enjoy making others recipes as they were meant to be made. So with all of that said, I thought it would be nice to start a new series called What I’m Cooking, where I will write about a recipe I found somewhere and my experiences with it (successes, failures, challenges, etc).

The first recipe was roasted potato & bacon salad, but I didn’t really talk much about the series… so I’m going to pretend that this is the real first official post in the series and hopefully you can all pretend along with me! So, the first feature is the Meringue Dream Cake by Sweetapolita. I actually first saw this cake pop up on Sweetapolita’s instagram feed – the next minute I was on Pinterest adding it to my own board. I usually just add cakes to my Pinterest because they are baking porn to me. And I’m often delusional thinking I’m going to actually bake them. But this cake was somehow different – the timing on that post couldn’t have been better because earlier that day my brother had asked me if I would be willing to bake a cake for his girlfriend’s birthday in a few weeks. I guess he caught me at a moment of weakness because I agreed. Normally when it comes to making something in the kitchen, I’m all over it. But baking a cake, or just baking in general, is another story. I am not much of a baker. It’s not that I’m bad at it, it’s that I prefer to cook. Regardless, I couldn’t back out of making a cake. When my brother proposed the idea, I actually had a different cake in mind that I have been wanting to try out for awhile – it’s a dark chocolate salted caramel cake from The Duchess Bakeshop cookbook (don’t worry, I will still make it, just another time). But as soon as I saw the Dream Cake, I knew that was the cake I needed to make. I sent the recipe to my brother and he immediately replied “YES!”.

Meringue Dream Cake

I made the cake over a few days – the baked meringues two days early, the cake and chocolate glaze the day before, then on the day of serving I made the meringue frosting and assembled the cake. All of the steps were really simple and I’m very glad I spread the process out over a few days.

Meringue Dream Cake

Here are my overall thoughts on this recipe:
– You might be put off when you first look at the recipe and see all the different steps, but almost everything except the frosting can be done a few days ahead like what I did. It is a time consuming cake, but it was worth it for a special occasion.
– I did use food coloring powder as recommended and found it online at Golda’s Kitchen (based out of Canada but they ship to the US as well). I had a bit of trouble with the coloring because since I am not much of a baker, I haven’t had to color anything since the time my sister and I made green pancakes for our Dad when we were younger. The blue was actually perfect, but the green turned out much more pastel than I wanted (I was going for emerald). I don’t blame the coloring, I’m blaming my lack of experience.
– If you don’t have all the ingredients on hand, it can be a pricey cake. I purchased food coloring powder, edible glitter, lots of eggs (the recipe uses 16 in total!), buttermilk, a round cake pan (I did not own one prior to this – tells you how much I bake), and frosting tips. You don’t need to purchase all of these things to make the cake (specifically the coloring and glitter), but since it was for a birthday, and for a person who loves color, I wanted to make sure it was extra special.
– I don’t know much about cake baking. I know that there is this whole big world of cake baking that exists that I am totally ignorant to. So when I discovered that lining the bottom of your cake pan with parchment paper to prevent the cake from sticking is a thing, I slapped my hand to my forehead. Of course, how brilliant!
– I was mostly worried about piping the meringues and them looking like hell, but it was surprisingly easy. My only issue was that I don’t think my mixture was firm enough because the meringues quickly lost their shape. They didn’t look horrible, but they could have been much better. I’ll take it as a baking lesson I suppose.
– Almost half of my larger meringues cracked while baking. I read up on this afterwards and it looks like I wasn’t using the freshest eggs, which is what can cause cracking. Also, I could have baked my meringues too long and I should have turned off the oven and let them gradually cool before taking them out. Apparently meringues are very finicky. It’s not a big deal, I used the good meringues for decorating and the cracked ones got crushed up for the cake layers or eaten on their own – they still tasted amazing.
– You’ll have a lot of egg yolks left over so you’ll want to make Martha Stewart’s Bittersweet Chocolate Mousse (it is really easy & quick to make. And also so good).

So would I recommend this recipe to others? Yes, especially if it is a special occasion. It doesn’t require a lot of decorating skill, which is good, and all of the steps are very easy and straight forward. Not to mention, this cake tastes amazing.

2 thoughts on “What I’m Cooking: Meringue Dream Cake

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s